Jump to content

Paladins falling, but not to Evil


Andyr

Recommended Posts

The classic example of a fallen Paladin seems to be one who has turned to Evil.

 

I am trying to think of situations which could lead a Paladin to fall in the other direction--ones that would mean they lose their status as a result of becoming NG or CG in alignment. However, I cannot think of that many situations which would warrant a shift that way. Such as, perhaps, lying to protect some perceived greater good. Is anyone feeling imaginative? Any thoughts?

Link to comment

Maybe it just occured to the Paladin that the lawful path is not always the best one. There are lots of reasons a Paladin might become unlawful. It could just slowly dawn on the Paladin that his straight jackeded ethos was actually stopping him from doing as much good as he otherwise could (thus he becomes neutral good) or he might slowly come to see the importance of individual freedom in a new light (and he becomes chaotic). I don't think a catastrophic event is needed. In my experience, people don't change their nature over night. Such change may or may not be triggered by some grand event, but big changes in one's world view of are generally the product of time and life experience. A Paladin who leaded a more or less cloistered life is quite likely to change some of his viewpoints on the nature and purpose of law in his travels. I think it would be quite common for such sheltered people to have radical shifts in their perspective upon encountering the real world.

Link to comment
Guest notasophist

what about Keldorn's dilemma with an adulterous wife? He mentioned that the laws dictates him to turn her in and have her hanged (or something like that)?

 

I would imagine that is an instance which a paladin may choose forgiveness (morally good, as far as i know) over law. Thus technically this choice can be considered unlawful.

Link to comment
Guest notasophist
I think there needs to be a distinction between chosing not to enforce a law, and chosing not to obey a law.

 

Yes, i agree there is a difference. However, I believe chosing not to enforce a law is still unlawful -- in the instance of a corrupt cop or a compassionate paladin.

 

Then again, just everyone has their own idea of lawful/chaotic. I believe that, fundamentally, a lawful good person cannot exist in an evil political system...

Link to comment
what about Keldorn's dilemma with an adulterous wife? He mentioned that the laws dictates him to turn her in and have her hanged (or something like that)?

 

This probably comes back to godly interpretation of the law and whose law takes precedence. As Keldorn is the one who has been wronged (in the legal sense), by forgiving his wife, Keldorn removes the wrong and thus his duty as a paladin of Torm to right it. Amnian law evidently doesn't recognise this, but by Torm's laws of competing duty, Keldorn has done the right and lawful thing.

Link to comment

It's also important to point that if one is both Lawful and Good, these two ideals will inevetabely come into conflict with each other from time to time. Occassionally siding with Good over Law or vice versa isn't likely to change your alignment.

Link to comment

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...